A Knot is Not a Fault in the Rope: Rethinking Trauma Therapy

Written by John Walter

A rope with one tight knot in the middle against a green and orange watercolour sky, illustrating a relational approach to trauma therapy.

I’ve started using rope to explain something about trauma therapy that I find hard to say any other way. People often arrive for a first conversation already braced, as though the work ahead is going to mean being pulled apart and made to live through the worst of it again. That expectation does real damage before anyone has said a word, because it turns the idea of getting help into something to be endured rather than something that might actually help.

So I reach for rope. Picture a length of it with a knot pulled tight in the middle. The knot isn’t a flaw in the rope; the rope was sound. Something happened, and under strain it bound up to hold. That’s what a knot is, and it’s where I’d start with anyone wondering whether trauma therapy is worth beginning.

A knot is not a fault in the rope

This is the part people find hardest to believe about themselves. When something frightening or too much happens, whether it’s one event or years of a situation you couldn’t leave, you do what you have to do to stay in one piece. You brace yourself and carry on. You keep half an eye on everything, or you close a door on a feeling because there was nowhere safe to put it. None of that is weakness, and none of it is damage. It’s the rope binding up under load, doing what rope does when it’s asked to hold more than it should. The difficulty comes later, when the strain has passed but the knot is still there, still holding as though the danger never left.

Why trauma therapy doesn’t have to mean forcing

Most of what people dread about trauma therapy is the forcing. The picture of being marched back into the memory and cracked open so the bad thing can be pulled out. Take the rope again. Pull hard on both ends of a knotted rope and it doesn’t come loose; it binds tighter. People are no different. Push someone to confront the worst of it before there’s any safety in the room and the holding gets stronger, not weaker, because the pressure registers as more of the same threat. I’ve watched that happen and I’ve no interest in causing it. The work was never about forcing anything out of you, and a good deal of my job is making sure it doesn’t turn into that.

A knot loosens when there’s slack

What a knot actually needs is slack. Take the tension off, give it time, and the turns that were locked solid start to have a bit of play in them. Then it can be worked loose without a fight. In therapy the slack is the relationship. It’s being met as you are, including the parts of you that had to go into hiding to get you through the thing in the first place. A knot doesn’t loosen because someone attacked it; it loosens because the conditions around it changed enough that it no longer had to hold so hard. That happens between two people, in a room where you’re not being asked to stay braced, which is also why so much of this is difficult to do entirely on your own.

Not fixed, but changed

I want to be honest about where this leads, because healing often gets sold as a return to some untouched earlier version of yourself. Rope that has carried a knot keeps something of it. There may be a mark where the turns pressed in. What changes is that the rope can move freely again; it’s no longer stopped at one point, holding a shape from years ago. This isn’t being fixed, in the sense of a fault put right. It’s being changed. You carry what happened, and it stops running things from underneath.

A different place to start

If the thought of trauma therapy has been something to brace against, I’d offer this as a different place to begin. The aim isn’t to force a confession out of you or to march you through the worst day of your life on a timetable. It’s to make enough room, over time and alongside someone, that what’s been held too tightly for too long can start to have some give in it. I work this way in person in Bude and online across the UK, and the first step is only ever a conversation. If any of this lands, a free phone call is a good place to find out whether it’s a fit.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Get new tools by email

Sign up and I'll let you know when I add a new free tool, plus the odd post on relationships and therapy along the way. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Discover more from John Walter Counsellor

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading